Showing posts with label theology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label theology. Show all posts

Swine Flu

10:11 AM Reporter: Justin 0 Responses
Thinking about the possible spread of Swine Flu has caused me to ask myself several questions. First off, is it really right to discriminate against people who are sick. At first, I think yes. For the greater good of society, we should confine those who may spread an epidemic. At the same time though, I understand it is wrongly limiting the life of a human being. That person has the same God-given rights as me, and should have the same freedoms. Perhaps a solution to this question would be for society to be able to confine the person for a pre-determined amount of time, but be required to provide for that person's needs, so as not to limit there inherit freedom.

Additionally, did God cause this (possible) epidemic? A good Calvinist would say "yes". I am more convinced that one of the results of sin entering the world (and in Genesis 3 the earth itself is cursed) is that there are bad things happening on the earth. So, this (possible) epidemic is just one of those bad things. At the same time God provides a way for humanity to get through circumstances like this. So, God probably hasn't caused this, but he is active in sustaining his people through it.

More thoughts later...

Read more...

Recycling as an Act of Worship: An Argument from the Old Testament

10:18 AM Reporter: Justin 0 Responses
I recently presented a paper with this title at the Southwest Regional meeting of the Evangelical Theological Society. The paper was well-received, though I would have wished for more input (don't we all!).

The basic argument of the paper proceeds like this:
1. Worship in the Bible is defined as fulfilling God's commands.
2. One of God's commands is to care for his creation.
3. Creation Care is an act of Worship.
4. Qualifications for what makes an act of service (e.g. creation care) an act of worship.
5. Recycling is an act of Creation Care.
6. Recycling is an act of Worship, and conclusions...

You can read the paper at: http://www.clickcaster.com/conservativeecology

Read more...

Morning in the Garden

8:11 AM Reporter: Justin 0 Responses

Today as I was walking from my car to the library at SWBTS, I realized that this morning was probably a lot like the mornings in the garden of creation.

The cool of the morning glides against my face, and gives me energy in my lungs. The sun glows behind the clouds. It's warm tones filter through the oak trees. The light shimmers on the dewy grass. The air smells clean. The air smells like trees, and flowers. The birds sing and call to one another. Everything seems to be coming awake as I drink my coffee.

I can almost imagine the story of Genesis 2 taking place in a setting much like this. The story portrays God as a gardener among his people.

How are we treating the garden? How are we treating the gardener?

Read more...

British Eco-Hypocrites

4:05 PM Reporter: Justin 0 Responses

Evidently most Brits are only "green" on a part-time basis. The article which details this can be found here. Interestingly, the farther up the scale of being committed to an earth conscious lifestyle, the more likely the people are to take long flights. Why does this seem odd to me? Long flights are supposed to be really bad for the environment.

To be fair, I suspect that most people here in the USA aren't as earth conscious as people in Britain, and Europe, and Japan. Even though many Texans aren't environmentalists, they are not hypocritical about it. But, that's neither here nor there.

I'm really interested if the data in this study was obtained through a survey or hard data. If it was a survey, then it is likely that many who were considered eco-saints lied about their behavior "on holiday".

This subject of earth conscious (or "green") vacationing gave me an idea. Why don't some airlines start a "green" fair? They could include an offset as part of the price of the ticket. I wonder how well those would sell.

I take trips to see family frequently. When we travel, we are definitely less careful about how we dispose of waste products, and where we eat. This has not been because of a conscious choice, instead it is because we -like the brits- don't think about it.

Read more...

Review of "After Nature's Revolt" part-1

2:05 PM Reporter: Justin 0 Responses

After Nature's Revolt Is a collection of essays edited by Dieter T. Hessel. "The contributors to this book share three assumptions. First, the world faces unprecedented environmental peril that will have profound ecological and social effects. Second, this situation exposes major problems in the (Western) Christian tradition and stimulates theological-ethical rethinking to meet the future. Third, the church has a special mission and responsibility for eco-justice in these times (p2)." To some degree I agree with all of these assumptions. However as you will see, I do not believe the tradition needs as much rethinking as they do. One statement I can agree with is that "Covenant theology and statutes expect eco-justice to be done. Exodus 23, Leviticus 19 and 25, plus Deuteronomy 15 emphasize the religious obligation of faithful people to give animals Sabbath rest and to let the land lie fallow at least once every seven years (p11)."


John Cobb, Jr wrote the first article titled, "Postmodern Christianity in Quest of Eco-Justice." In it he says, "All are in God and God is in all. Not a sparrow falls to the ground apart from God's participatory knowledge. When we inflict suffering on a whale, God suffers with it. When we make possible the healty functioning of the biosphere, God enjoys the vitality (24)." The beginning of that statement reeks of panentheism, which is unnacceptable for an evangelical like myself. But then he goes on to say, "These practical and attitudinal changes are rooted in the postmodern theological rejection of the dualism of body and mind. That does not mean that here is no distinction between bodily and mental activity. But all experience is both physical and mental. There is no mere matter and there is no mere mind. The extended and thinking substances of Descartes do not exist. This means also that the dualism between human beings and other animals is not real. They, too, are at once physical and mental. And, indeed, we cannot draw sharp lines between animals and the other creatures tha make up our world with us (p25)." I disagree. Humans are very distinct from animals, in that there were no suitable helpers for humanity to be found among the animals. God chose humans to have a special relationship with in his garden, and to be his image-bearers (Gen 1-2).


Larry Rasmussen wrote the 2nd article, "Returning to our Senses: The Theology of the Cross as a Theology for Eco-Justice". One interesting statement that he makes is, "The meaning of finitum copax inifiniti is simple enough: God is pegged to the earth. So if you would experience God, you must love the earth. The infinite and transcendent are always dimensions of what is intensely at hand. Don't look up for God, look around. The finite is all there is because all that is, is there (41)." From this statement and another on p42, he asserts that Luther was panentheistic (Luther said the latin phrase). But, this one interpretation of the phrase seems to be at odds with much else that Luther said. It seems to be a case of letting the ambiguous small phrase replace the un-ambiguous volumes of things that Luther said.


The third and final article to be reviewed today was written by Paul H. Santmire, "Healing the Protestant Mind: Beyond the Theology of Human Dominion." As you may have guessed he calls into question what he percieves as the dominant Protestant trend of God as the monarchical creator, and humanity having dominion over creation.


He says, "By the time of Karl Barth, the Reformers' the-anthropocentric focus had been systematized, especially by theologians who wrote in the tradition of Immanuel Kant and Albrecht Ritschl. Such thinkers taught that God cannot be known in nature, and they often implied that God cannot even be encountered in nature (p62)." Having only read one work by each of those authors, I cannot comment accurately about them "often" making those type of comments. He goes on to say, "One difference [between new eological thinking and old] becomes immediately apparent. In keeping with the promissory character of the metaphor of migration to a good land, and in response ot the eschatology that shaped the teachings of Jesus and the theology of Paul, the final fulfillment becomes the integrating construct in this ecological theology, rather than the eternal beginning as is the case in Barth's thought (p70)." If you have read elsewhere in my blog, I believe that an evangelical's philosophy of ecology (or doctrine of ecology if you want) grows out of their doctrine of creation. I see it as a subset of creation-theology.


Santmire goes on to call for changes in the doctrine of God. "This God creates a space within the divine being, withdrawing to allow the cosmos to have its own place. In this schema the cosmos is not dominated by a distant and therefore overpowering divine otherness, as some Protestant images of God, including Barth's, have sometimes suggested. This God is one who is most characteristically revealed in the humility of the cross, whose power is weakness. This is a God who can enter intimately and immediately into an interactive history with all creatures, not one who controls them like puppets (p72)." To me, this sounds too close to open-theism, which is unacceptable to me and most other evangelicals (at least members of ETS).


One of the most ambiguous statements is when he is speaking of redefining humanity's relationship with nature. Instead of domination by humans (as he labels the Protestant view), he calls for an "I-Ens, the the latter pointing to a relationship of contemplation and cooperation with nature (75)." He says this in the context of a discussion which concludes that humanity cannot have an I-thou (Martin Buber's terminology) relationship with nature. So, he invents his own category so as to avoid the I-It relationship. This isn't a bad idea. I actually agree that we as humans need to appreciate nature more. But, he fails to substantially explain what this difference looks like, and leaves the reader confused.


The rest of this review will come in another post later...

Read more...

Emphasis upon Ecology = a Corruption of the Doctrine of Redemption?

11:12 AM Reporter: Justin 0 Responses

green & blue
Originally uploaded by Martjusha

An emphasis on ecology has lead some to rethink terms such as “sin” and “redemption”. When considering these themes in light of ecology, some have come to understand these terms in new ways. Sin has been interpreted as “wrong relationship”, and redemption is seen as restoring people and the environment to the proper relationship (Rosemary Radford Reuther. Gaia and God: An Ecofeminist Theology of Earth Healing. San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1992, 168).
Certainly this redefinition of the doctrine of redemption has occurred as a result of emphasizing ecology. But, this new definition is largely unacceptable to evangelicals. How can this pitfall be avoided?
Evangelicals must be clear about the position ecology occupies within their theology (worldview). When working alongside others who define redemption in terms of restoring the right relationship with the environment (not with God), evangelicals must be clear from the beginning that they differ with their colleagues in terms of ideology but have enough common ground to work with them.
Even by continually emphasizing the differences between an evangelical understanding of redemption and an eco-feminist understanding of redemption (Ruether’s words), some in the secular realm will no doubt fail to recognize the difference. This can only be counteracted if the evangelical church at large teaches the proper place of ecology as one that is a sub-category of creation, and not the major emphasis of the faith. If churches are consistent in this teaching then evangelicals as well as media should be able to make the distinction between an evangelical understanding and an eco-feminist understanding of redemption.

Read more...

10 Old Testament theologians addressing Ecology

4:28 PM Reporter: Justin 0 Responses
This picture is located in Mullah Jacob's Synagogue in Isfahan, close to Jame Mosque. Originally uploaded to Flickr by HORIZON.


The Old Testament
Originally uploaded by HORIZON
You may notice that I added a sidebar link to 10 Old Testament Theologians who deal with the topic of ecology.

Four of these were primary sources in my thesis. Of those four, Terence Fretheim's God and World gives the most attention to the topic of ecology. He is inventive in his thinking, but opts for a panentheistic view of God, and incorporates the open-theism of process theology. Then, John Goldingay's Old Testament Theology vol. 1; along with Walter Brueggemann's Old Testament theology, give ample attention to the topic. Goldingay is for the most part a good fit for evangelicals, as far as the doctrine of God as Creator goes. Brueggemann is a little harder to peg because of his method of doing Old Testament Theology. He a different view of ecology present in each of his three categories of testimony about God found within the Old Testament. Bruce Waltke in his Old Testament Theology gives the least attention to this topic. His theology is probably a "normal" evangelical church-goer's idea of the doctrine of God, and ecology. It is a peripheral subject for him.

Ellen F. Davis is currently working on a book entitled Scripture, Culture, and Agriculture: An Agrarian Reading of the Bible which will be published later this year. She has also written articles dealing with ecology and the Old Testament. She teaches at Duke University.

Howard Wallace, Ellen Van Wolde, Eugene C. McAfee, and Norman C. Habel are all contributers to the Earth Bible Project.

Carol Newsom is Charles Howard Candler Professor of Old Testament at Emory University. You may know her from the Women's Bible Commentary (1998).

All of these scholars are developing new ways of better understanding God's relationship to his creation, and how humanity should stand in relationship to creation (ecology).

Read more...